Cakes

Please click here for Our Special Dietary Items

Don't be fooled by bakeries that advertise "all-inclusive prices" and say they do not "add-on charges" for complex designs or fondant. What they actually mean by this is that they charge complex design prices for all their cakes and if you choose a simple design, that is just a bonus for them!

At The Buttercream Boutique, we price by the serving, according to detail. Because the ingredient costs are minimal, design variations are the most costly factor in determining the the final price of your cake. You may want to look at many bakeries and speak to many people people before you find a baker that is a good fit with what you are looking for, with a value that fits your budget. 

 

Prices for a two layer, 4 1/2” tall cake, start at $3.50 a serving for American Buttercream or whipped icing, and $4.50 per serving for Fondant or other Premium covered cakes. Each tier has 2 layers of cake, torted and filled with icing between the layers. One filling per tier is included. There will be extra charges for intricate details (basket weave), excessive amounts of icing flowers or pearls, fondant or gum paste embellishments, lengthy preparation, costly ingredients, or satellite cakes. Each tier of your cake may be a different flavor for no additional charge.

 

Carved cakes, such as Topsy Turvy or Elaborate 3D cakes must be covered in fondant and pricing starts at $5 a serving. Your carved cake may be more “dense”, and some “slippery” fillings and icings may not be available due to issues with collapsing or slipping during transport. 3D and other sculpted cakes are impossible to get a precise serving count, but a close estimate can be obtained by adding up the serving count of each cake it is “built” from, and subtracting the 10% to 15% that is carved off. They can also be tricky to serve, so you must be creative when cutting them!


We have many options listed and are always open to new flavors if you have a special request. We can also mix in your favorite candy bar or cookie!  Or try infusing the cake with your favorite flavor syrup, extract, or alcohol for an extra kick and added moisture.

You may choose as many flavors as there are cakes. However, keep in mind that the top 2 tiers are fairly small. It may be best to make these two top tiers the same flavor. However, if the bottom tier of your cake is a 16” (serves 98) you may choose two cake flavors to make it a “half and half”for an additional $10. The same type of filling must be used in both halves, like mousse, or fruit, or buttercream.

 

 

Cakes

Fillings

 

Stir-Ins & Toppings

add .15¢ per serving

Infusions

add 10¢ per serving

Almond

Apple

Almonds

Almond

Banana

Apricot*

Andes Mints

Chocolate

Birthday Cake

Banana Cream

Butterfingers

Coconut Milk

Buttermilk

Bavarian Cream

Butterscotch Chips

Espresso

Butterscotch

Blueberry*

Caramel Chips

Guava

Chocolate

Caramel Cream

Chocolate Chips

Cola

Chocolate Chip

Cheesecake Fluff

Heath

Mango

Choc. Chip Cookie

Cherry*

M & M's

Mint

Chocolate Mint

Chocolate Buttercream

Oreo

Orange

Cinnamon Swirl

Choc. Chip Cookie Dough

Peanut Butter Chips

Raspberry

Coconut

Chocolate Mousse

Reese's Cup

Root Beer

Dark Chocolate

Coffee Cream

Snickers

 

Egg Nog

Coconut Cream

Sprinkles

Alcoholic

French Vanilla

Cookies & Cream

Vanilla Chips

add .25¢ per serving

Fruit Swirl*

Ganache

Vanilla Wafers

Amaretto

German Chocolate

Lemon*

Walnuts

Apple

Gingerbread

Mango

White Chocolate Chips

Bailey's Irish Cream

Lemon

Marshmallow Cream

Whoppers

Bourbon

Orange

Mocha Cream

York Peppermint Patties

Butterscotch

Pineapple

Mint Cream

Seasonal Candies

Godiva Chocolate

Red Velvet

Peach*

 

Hot Cinnamon

Root Beer

Peanut Butter Cream

Can be added to either

Kahlua

Spice

Pineapple*

cake or filling, or both!

Limoncello

Strawberry

Pistachio

 

Peach

White

Raspberry*

 

Peppermint

White Chocolate

Strawberry*

 

Raspberry Chambord

Yellow

 

 

 

 

*cream or glaze based

 

 

 

Popular Combinations

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ~ Chocolate Chip Cookie cake with Vanilla Mousse filling.
Orange Delight ~ Orange flavored cake with Pineapple Mousse filling.
Peanut Butter Cup ~ Chocolate cake with Peanut Butter Mousse filling.
Strawberry Shortcake ~ White cake with Strawberry Mousse filling.
Raspberry Almond ~Almond cake with Raspberry fruit filling.
Cookies & Cream ~ Dark Chocolate cake with Cookies & Cream filling.
Orange Dream ~ Orange cake filled with Vanilla mousse filling.
Peaches ‘n’ Cream ~ White cake infused with Peach & filled with Peach Mousse filling.
Piña Colada ~ Coconut cake filled with Pineapple filling.
Red Velvet ~ Red Velvet cake with Cream Cheese filling.
Strawberry Lemonade ~ Lemon cake & Strawberry Mousse filling.
Mounds/Almond Joy ~ Dark Chocolate cake with Coconut Cream filling with optional chopped almonds.

Seasonal Flavors

White Chocolate Peppermint

Gingerbread Orange Spice

Egg Nog Cinnamon Swirl